Data centers in Ireland: It’s too late to stop now

A Google data center near Dublin.

Ireland doesn't have the most data centers in Europe, but no other nation uses as much of its electricity supply to run them as Ireland.

America’s midterm elections provided plenty of surprises. The success of 40 out of 41 anti- data-center ballot measures wasn’t one of them. 

According to polls, office seekers could score points with voters (esp. Democrats) by opposing data center development. So, lots of them did. Especially in Texas, soon to become the world’s largest data center market.

But isn’t it too late to stop now? Or even declare a moratorium? 

Let’s look at Ireland and its data centers

How is Ireland, the most tech-friendly nation in Europe, handling the demand? That depends who you’re talking to. Either these centers provide a much-needed boost to the Irish economy or they’re a pain, a drain on the nation’s electricity and water supply and they need to be scaled back in the future.  

I have a theory about support for data centers in Ireland. Ireland’s a small country. Lots of people have jobs building data centers or working at one. In fact, it’s possible that a majority of people in Ireland knows one of those workers. Or knows someone who does. As Irish history shows, a good job means you don’t have to emigrate.

Data centers got an early start in Ireland back in 2015 because that’s where the biggest tech firms had planted their flags: Microsoft, Meta, Google and Amazon. There’s an estimated 80 to 130 data centers currently operating in Ireland, mostly in and near Dublin. Even though you could fit three Irelands (the entire island) inside Oregon’s borders, there are more data centers there than here. (Oregon has 111. The Columbia Gorge and Eastern Oregon are home to 60%. The rest are in and around Hillsboro.) 

Because Irish government and industry put up the Failte (Welcome) sign for data centers a decade ago, the tech giants and local energy entrepreneurs came and built centers that now consume close to one quarter of all the electricity in Ireland . Some say that will be one third by 2030. 

Taoiseach Micheal Martin

Ireland is open for business 

Why is Ireland so attractive to high tech? Data center providers choose Ireland for a number of reasons. Ireland is politically stable, with a very intelligent workforce, as well as "incredibly generous corporation tax profiles," Dr. Paul Deane of UC Cork told RTE in 2022. The corporation tax in Ireland is 12.5%, the second lowest in Europe. We also have a good climate for data centres; it’s not too hot and not too cold, we are geographically and tectonically stable, with no earthquakes, volcanoes or forest fires.” 

The Irish government seems to be all in on data center development. Here’s why: Numbers crunchers in Dublin estimate that since 2010 there’s been a great payoff: 17,000 jobs, 2.8 billion Euros in taxes paid and 22 billion Euros pumped into Ireland’s economy.  

 Taoiseach Micheal Martin warned the people of Ireland not to “demonize data centers” when he visited the White House last year. "We do need to step up. We can't just postpone AI. We can’t declare a moratorium on AI. We’d be left well behind if we do that." 

No other nation uses as much of its electricity supply to run data centers as Ireland.  They consume 23% of all the electricity used in the Republic of Ireland. Here in the U.S., about 5,000 data centers use less than 5% of U.S. electricity (which is still a lot). No other nation comes close to using as much electricity on data centers as Ireland. 

Some of the 2,341 wind turbines currently operating in Ireland. These are located in Connemara.

So, what’s Ireland to do?  More wind power. 

"I think our problems will ease off with off-shore wind, that will come on-stream in [a] significant sort of critical mass in the early 2030s. So, I think we can see where the end game or the promised land is in respect of offshore wind," said the Taoiseach. 

Tell that to the protestors from Counties Kildare, Louth, Waterford, Wicklow and Clare who were among those marching from Parnell Square to Leinster House last weekend and demanding a moratorium on new data centers in Ireland. There were an estimated 2,000 of them, RTE reported. Which, in the scheme of such things, isn’t a huge crowd. 

There were 300 protestors in Co. Waterford the second weekend in October protesting plans for a major data center development project in the village of Kilmeaden. Irish media is rife with outrage.

"If this is built, there's no going back. We're not getting the village back. Most of us grew up here, born and bred. We know what it's like to grow up in a village. And this will completely destroy that," said Amanda Power, one of the organizers of the wee protest. 

"The thought of three big data centres going in, a massive solar farm, a gas power plant, essentially, and all the infrastructure that comes with that, not to mention the noise and the traffic. It's so much to expect the residents of a small village to just accept." 

What the polls show

.The Irish Times released a poll on September 26 which reveals “real and mounting concern.” It (data center development) has yet to produce the kind of grassroots revolt now under way across America, but that may only be a matter of time.

Asked whether more data centers should be built or construction halted for the time being, 61 per cent of respondents chose a pause, against 23 per cent in favour of further building. Opposition cuts across party lines. Majorities of every party’s supporters favour a halt, including among the two main Government parties, where 56 per cent of Fine Gael voters and 54 per cent of Fianna Fáil voters agree.

Next
Next

Spy vs Spy